Alan Milburn’s independent review of youth unemployment, published on 17 November 2026, recommends cutting employer National Insurance on staff under 25. It wants retail and hospitality to go first. The two sectors provide almost 40% of the jobs held by young people at risk of being out of work, which puts franchised restaurant and coffee operators close to the proposal.
The report was commissioned a year ago to address the number of young people not in employment, education or training. According to official figures cited by the BBC, there are nearly one million 16 to 24-year-olds in that position in the UK. The National Insurance proposal is the measure employers have watched most closely, because it bears directly on payroll. Employer National Insurance is a UK-wide tax, so any change would apply in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland alike.
What the review proposes on National Insurance
The central recommendation concerns workers aged 21 to 24. Today, employers pay 15% National Insurance on their annual earnings above £5,000. Milburn proposes doubling that threshold to £10,000, phased in over five years and “when fiscal conditions allow”, according to The Caterer. Employers already pay no National Insurance on staff under 21, nor on apprentices under 25, unless they earn above £50,270. The current regime dates from April 2025, when the rate rose from 13.8% and the threshold fell from £9,100. The review stops short of an immediate cut for the whole age group: the Resolution Foundation has put the cost of removing employer National Insurance on 21 to 24-year-olds at once at £5.1 billion.
What it would mean for hospitality payrolls
Trade body UKHospitality has put numbers on the threshold change. It estimates that around 240,000 hospitality jobs would qualify, with an annual saving of £750 for each eligible full-time employee and about £170 million a year across the sector. On those figures, a pub employing 20 young people would save around £15,000 a year. For a franchisee running several quick-service sites, the saving would scale with the number of 21 to 24-year-olds on the rota.
Allen Simpson, chief executive of UKHospitality, said: “Increasing the employer NICs threshold for young people working in hospitality would be a bold and significant recommendation from Alan Milburn.” He added that the industry body wants the change made in April, the earliest opportunity.
Yearly saving UKHospitality expects for the sector from a £10,000 threshold

Good to know
As an independent review, its recommendations do not change any rate on their own. A change to employer National Insurance would have to be announced by the Government and legislated before HMRC applies it.
The welfare side of the report
Beyond National Insurance, Milburn proposes that under-25s should no longer be able to claim the health element of Universal Credit or personal independence payment. He wants a legal guarantee of a job, training or employment support, with benefits at risk for those who refuse it. Separately, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said on Sunday that the Government’s subsidised jobs guarantee for 18 to 24-year-olds on Universal Credit will be extended. It will cover people who have claimed for 12 months rather than 18, in England, Scotland and Wales.
What happens next
The Government has not yet said whether it will adopt the threshold change, or on what timetable. Employer National Insurance has been one of the main cost lines cited by hospitality operators since April 2025. Milburn himself has said the youth unemployment problem did not start with that increase. The next fixed point for any change to employer contributions is the April start of the tax year, which is the date the hospitality trade body has asked for.











